I was all ready to come back here and blast you for this "the league got back at them by letting the Giants win" theory, but then last night I was thinking...
A. What better possible scenario could there be for the NFL's marketing department than for another Manning to win the SB, and to have a team from NY win the SB, and to do it by knocking off the "unbeatable" Patriots?
B. What better way is there to try to quiet down all of the cheating talk than to MAKE SURE the Patriots lost that game? It still won't go away, but imagine how much louder it would be if they had gone 19-0? I know I, for one, would have been in here talking about how they should have been, at a minimum, 18-1, because I can't figure out for the life of me why they didn't have to forfeit the Jets game - I mean, really, in what other sport in the world can a team get caught cheating DURING A GAME and not have to forfeit that game?
C. It at least sort of explains Belichick's actions after the game - he kind of had an "let's get this over with" air about him, but not in a "I'm mad we just lost" kind of way... it was more like, "ok, if this is what we have to do, but I'm not happy about it..."
Now, all that being said, I still think the Giants just handed the Patriots their arses in a handbag last night - I can't find anything in my memory to suggest that anything during the game was unfair toward the Giants, other than the play of NE's offensive line - and I doubt they were all in on it... but it does make for interesting fodder for conspiracy theorists.