Sure is. To me, if you pay a monthly fee for a service and they stop delivering the service for whatever reason, it's their responsibility to fix the problem or refund you your money and waive any contractual obligations. I know that's not the law, but there is such a thing as an ethical responsibility in this world. Not everything that's legal is right. Even the cable company will come out and fix the equipment they are leasing you, or replace it, for free if your service stops working, and cable companies are not exactly models of perfect customer service themselves, but even they do this bare minimum without tacking on a surcharge.
How can you compare an RG-6 line coming into a home with a satellite that can be affected by so many different things? Wind, rotting wood, kids hanging from it, etc... Most consumers want this installed FREE. What is the price difference from an HD satellite + cable compared to just a length of cable? You cannot compare receivers as cable companies charge a monthly fee per box as well.
There are some shady things going on with the way DN does things. However, if you had all you equipment installed for free, and your buddy got drunk and decided to do a tarzan off your dish into the pool, you shouldn't expect DN to send someone out to fix it for free.
HD for life customers should have all the standard HD channels. This Palladia deal is messed up.