Of course I was trying to be helpful and not sarcastic. We've seen some DISH techs here post the most ridiculous things. Nobody here or anywhere for that matter puts much faith in what they're told by DISH techs or CSR's. It's hit or miss whether what you're told will be accurate or just made up because it's what you want to hear or is what will get you off the phone. That's why most folks here use DIRT. The DIRT folks usually know what they're talking about.
Getting past all that drama and nonsense to get to the point;
I thought I read where you posted earlier that these unprovoked recordings were being made even after you unhooked the SJ. That right there disproves what the DISH tech told you. I've had a lot of experience firsthand with SJ's on the old and new UI's and have never heard of nor can I conceive a way that the SJ is responsible for the behavior you describe. That's all I was trying to tell you.
I wondered the same thing when I unplugged the SJ. However, I did not do any rebooting of the HWS, which could have made a difference. Also, it is possible that the SJ had already "planted" the upcoming phantom timers in the HWS? I probably should have left the SJ unconnected for a day or two to see what happens.
In any case, I'll be getting a Hopper3 to replace this one and hopefully everything will be okay. If not, I shudder to think of the wild recordings with SIXTEEN tuners. LOL
Thanks again for trying to be helpful. Much appreciated.