The last time I checked, my friends D* HD looked pretty good. I didn't think it looked at good as my FiOS...but I tweak my HDTVs and, to be honest, the difference was minimal. I would not be unhappy if I were an D* HD customer. Having said that, there are a lot of factors involved...HDMI typically looks better on a digital set (HDMI looks better than component on my Mits Diamond DLP), components typically looks better than on a CRT RPTV and, to honest, I couldn't tell the difference between HDMI and components on my Sony 3LCD RPTV (native resolution something like 768). Although it is hard to do a direct comparison on my Mits DLP (it doesn't have PIP), I didn't notice a difference between my 6416 (HDMI), CableCard, and OTA. Of course, I tweaked all three inputs.I currently (for the time being) have both DTV and now Fios. It seems to me the HD is also a little softer on Fios than DTV which really surprised me. But on that point I don't know if the reason is related to my having to go to component because the HDMI port on the 6416 died. I'm also a little worried that the installers reused existing cable company coax to bring it on from the poi...they tested the cabling and said it was good though. Any thoughts?
Offhand, I really don't know how well the Motorola box fares against the other cable boxes, but I can tell you that I didn't noticed a significant difference between the 6416 and the Tivo HD box we used for almost a month. If anything, I think the 6416 looked a little better, but the difference would have been insignificant, if anything at all.