I have a couple of those slip-on connectors and I'd feel more comfortable using that vs a screw-on connector with the wrong thread. My UHF antenna (a combo, actually) already has the connector though. I do have two sets of rabbit ears that have terminal ends that can be connected to the slip-on connector. Will it, a VHF antenna, work ? Maybe it will....WOW, that's great it is working much better for you. I am going to get out my Radio Shack powered rabbit ears and install one of them there slip on connectors to the coax and then attach it to the Hopper and see how she works.
I can't believe that the inner conductor (stinger ?) is even making a connection with as little thread that I got on.