Dish should license SpinRite and incorporate it in their DVR's. SpinRite works for TiVo's and any HDD for any use. I find it unacceptable that some Dish STB's try to correct or just report a few recordings messes-up and the software seems to NOT close off thsoe sectors--YES, for DVR formatting those sectors are much larger, but it seems to re-use problem sectors because the HDD/box can keep humming along until it a recordings goofs up, and if not much erased from the HDD, same thing, until lots are erased. I would rather put-up with an 8 hour or even 24 hour SpinRite attempt than a 48 hour to 4-5 day (if requested at the end of the week) time to get my replacement shipped to me, and lose all my recordings. Even if it is a 1 and half day scan, SpinRite could end up saving my recordings for transfer or at least continue to work. BUT that costs Charlie MONEY. Guess we'll never see it.