bhelms- Your PA rates are very close to what my Dad paid last year in PA. The rates are extremely cheap in PA.
Home owner's Insurance is one of the few very high cost requirements we have here. My house is 2000 sq ft too and Last year we shopped the best we could and that was $1750. The company( Travelers- KAB)we had prior to that jacked our rates from $1600 to $2350 from 2008 to 2009. Never had any claims.
When did we have our last hurricane in Jacksonville? 1964 The problem is we are told it has to do with the claims filed in Florida for Hurricane Andrew mostly and Florida residents have paid dearly since. The good news is we only pay a fraction of real estate taxes here. I pay $468 for county and school tax. My Dad paid nearly $6000 for those taxes in 2008 in PA. His home was 1100 Sq FT but on 4 acres. We sold it last April for $250,000. My home here in FL has an appraised value of $240,000. So, when I do the end of the day cost to live here, I take my high insurance rates over PA any time.
In OK, I think the insurance companies are hitting you up on Tornado risk. There have been huge losses in Tornado alley last couple of years so you get to pay for living there.