C-Band is not as family friendly as the small dish. I currently have an H2H subscription, FTA and Roku, but my gf hates C-Band, FTA is too inconvenient and has no guide. Roku, she likes almost as much as Direct. Before I met my gf, she had Direct with all the goodies, and of course the cost. PVR, the ability to watch 3 different TV shows at the same time, and HD which does have a better picture quality the H2H in SD, plus your TV screen is filled instead of chopped. No matter what, I can't see the old fashion way of C-Band can compare to Direct or Dish when it comes to the whole family. Price-YES, Choices by way of A-La-Carte, YES, No contract, YES, Family friendly, NO.
And, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you can even watch shows or at least somehow tie your smart phone in with Direct and/or dish.
I'm not too sure what I'll do if/when they finally turn off H2H.
If this new receiver can bring back C-Band with as many or nearly as many choices as Direct or Dish, with the choice of HD, and can significantly beat the prices that Direct or Dish offer by a large enough margin to make it worth while, I'd probably spend upwards of $1200.00. Especially if it had a PVR.
Imho, that'll never happen because of the most important factor, Family Friendliness.