HD Camcorders: Not Ready for Prime Time?

Sean Mota

SatelliteGuys Master
Original poster
Supporting Founder
Sep 8, 2003
19,039
1,739
New York City
ENTIRE ARTICLE

I was at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas earlier this month, and it seemed that everything there was about high-definition video: Vendors were showing huge HDTVs, high-end HD camcorders, and high-definition satellite TV services. Pretty much the only thing that wasn't high-definition was the coffee in the press room, which was distinctly lacking the sharpness and clarity that most HD video systems offer. Anyway, all of this might make you think that it's the right time for the home-movie maker to think about getting on the bandwagon. But making HD movies is rather different than watching them, and there are several good reasons why it might still be too soon to go high def for your home movies.

The Sony HDR-HC1 has been a big seller since it was launched in July 2005. If you're planning on buying a new camcorder, you're probably considering it, even though it's expensive ($1600 to $2000, depending on where you buy). It shoots video in the same high-definition 1080i resolution that you get from an HD cable or satellite TV service. It records that video using a new format called High Definition Video, or HDV, which can store video at up to 1080i resolution on the same MiniDV tapes that standard-definition MiniDV camcorders use.

Editing HD Video
Working with the video that camcorders like the Sony HDR-HC1 produce can be a serious business: HD video contains four times the number of pixels that standard-definition video does, and it's much more heavily compressed. You need a powerful computer with plenty of memory to deal with this extra data and compression. For example, Pinnacle recommends a minimum of 512MB of system memory and a graphics card with 128MB of RAM for standard-resolution video, but that goes up to 1GB of system memory and a 256MB graphics card for working with 1080i HD video. That's a minimum requirement--the more memory, the merrier. And you'll need a speedy PC to edit HD video: I wouldn't touch it on anything less than a 2-GHz or faster machine, and the new dual-core chips from Advanced Micro Devices and Intel make a big difference.
There is plenty of software that supports editing high-def video, though. For example, the latest versions of Pinnacle Studio and Ulead MediaStudio Pro 8 can both import and edit files in HDV format. (Adobe's consumer-level video editing app Premiere Elements does not support editing HD video at the moment.)

But, to be fair, the HDR-HC1 can convert the footage you record from high definition to standard definition when you play it back, so if your computer can't handle HD video, you can record it in HD on the camcorder, then capture and edit it at standard definition, preserving the high-definition version for the future when you have a computer that's fast enough to work with it.


Playback Time
Although the high-definition video that these camcorders produce looks great when you play it back on an HDTV, at present there is no way to store HD video on a DVD. The only way to store HD video for playback is on your PC or on the same media that you used in your HD camcorder.
A new generation of high-definition optical media formats are coming soon. Products based on the HD-DVD and Blu-ray Disc formats are very expensive, however, and will remain so for the near future. HD-DVD players were announced at CES that will cost $499 and up; they'll be available in March. But you'll also need a new rewritable HD-DVD drive to write to the discs, which will cost you as much again. The story is the same with Blu-ray Disc: The players and recorders are going to be expensive for the time being.
There is one other option, though: KiSS recently announced a DVD player (the DP-600) that can play back high-definition files that have been compressed to Microsoft's Windows Media 9 format, so that could at least provide a stop-gap until the price of the HD-DVD and Blu-ray Disc players and writers fall to a reasonable level. And you can always play back the recorded video through the camcorder itself: Just don't expect to be able to write it out to disc with current equipment and preserve its quality.


The Bottom Line
HD camcorders are still cutting-edge technology: Some of the pieces of the puzzle are not yet in place. And making HD movies is about more than just pointing an HDV camcorder at your subject and shouting "action!" It involves big changes to the way you shoot, edit, and play back videos, and you should understand these before you start shooting.
 
I think the title of this article is a little misleading. I believe HD Camcorders ARE ready for prime time. It's just the rest of the parts - HD-DVD/Blu-ray recorder/player, HD editing software, beefy hardware, HDTV uptake - are not ready. I think it's amazing that a hand held HD camcorder can already be obtained for under $2K.

For those who are ready to be early adopters on the HD camcorder technology, can anyone recommend reviews/articles on camcorders that are currently available (like the Sony mentioned in the article) or will be available in the near future? Were any new models announced at CES?
 
I just started using the Sony HDR-HC1 and so far I like the ergonomics and ease of use. I will let you know later how the videos come out.
 
Editing is a pain in the butt, even with 1 GB of ram my computer still bombs out at times, and also at other times the sound goes out of sync for no real reason.
 
Sometimes over looked, memory amount and processor sizes are not always the culprits of a "bombing" system during intensive video processes. Having matched sets of true CAS2 memory (or CAS1 memory if you can find and afford it) is essential; these must be verified/tested. Some memory can run your PC very well day-to-day, even game or play DVDs, but then crap out when doing this process because of memory failures and overheating.

You must also have the correct memory timings and TONS, let me say this again, TONS of cooling for the case, memory, CPU and mobo chipsets. OVERHEATING! This is almost always overlooked, left at whatever came with the retail pack, left at default, or just "cheaped out" and filled with whatever was the lowest cost. To heck with temperature sensors and mob monitors, by the time they report, its too late; CRASH.

All that being said, I have seen 2Ghz Althon XP's with 1GB of matched CAS2 memory edit and process HD video; slowly. I prefer the Athlon 64/FX with 2GB, but the smaller config can and does work OK with nothing else running in the background.
 
Last edited:
Scott Greczkowski said:
Editing is a pain in the butt, even with 1 GB of ram my computer still bombs out at times, and also at other times the sound goes out of sync for no real reason.

Scott, what camcorder do you have?
 

Does the Direct TV HD TUNER require activation for just OTA?

Why 1080p?

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)