After experiencing multiple annoyances unrelated to HBOMax just since I got home from work with both Firestick and Roku devices, I have decided to bite the bullet and get an NVIDIA Shield. I hope it is better than the cheaper devices I have been using. In the span of about 30 minutes, the following happned:
1. My Living Room Firestick 4K experienced frozen video while watching Disney+ which could only be fixed by pulling the power, and then it was very sluggish.
2. So, I switched to my 2018 Roku Ultra, which was sluggish, so I rebooted it, and checked for updates.
3. There were none, but it was faster after the reboot, so I launched Disney+ to continue watching what I had started on the Firestick. I was using the Roku app on my iPhone 11 Pro with Bluetooth speakers so as to not disturb my wife who works from home. I got several Private Listening errors, and then the Roku crashed and rebooted.
4. I went through this twice before switching back to the Firestick 4K, which seemed like it was going to hang again for a few seconds before it started playing normally.
Everything (other than my iPhone 11 Pro) is connected via Gigabit Ethernet and I have Gigabit FIber from AT&T. There is really no reason for any communication issues locally. These are software issues and possibly under-powered hardware. The Shield should solve the hardware issue. Hopefully the software is better too, given the price.