Great discussion so far -
I have comcast in Dallas, HD offerings are: Discovery, ESPN, InHD and HBO (at least that I pay for) in addition to the locals which I watch OTA because of signal quality. Comcast On Demand is cool but I can live without. I need the HD DVR so I will buy the D* version and hope they offer a great credit when the MPG-4 does come out soon.
I know the channels are weak but the NFL is a bigger pull. I know they channels will increase. I'm excited about ESPN2, wish i had it for the World Cup games on now. However, just as they did last renewall with the NFL, I'm sure they will sign a very lucerative contract with the NFL to keep it.
I do have a problem with the larger picture though - why would D* keep everyone in the dark?
If anyone hears rumors, I'm sure it will be reported here.