According to this report, Fox offered to keep the channels on during negotiation, and Saint Dish refused.
It's not that simple, and you know it. Many of us are under contract and would have to pay a substantial sum to leave.
Look, we all have to weigh the pros and cons of different providers. I came back to Dish from DirecTV because the Hopper 3 is still the best DVR on the market by a good margin. PTAT is nice to have, folders are very handy, and the company is generally pretty easy to deal with when it comes to service and billing, which DirecTV is most assuredly not, in my experience. However, since I came back, the compression seems to have become more aggressive and channel disputes have taken away many channels that I watch on a regular basis. You can call it "whining" if you want, but these are the factors that I as a consumer have to weigh. I'm lucky enough to have many choices where I live.
One other thing,
according to this report, Fox offered to keep the channels on the air during negotiations, and Saint Dish refused. It's one report from one guy, so who knows how valid it is, but it's a data point in any case.