I understand HOA in townhouses/apartments, in this case you only own the inside of the house, not the outside nor the land. The HOA in these cases own the land and exterior, they have the right to say what you do with it. You also pay a condo/strata fee for this.
But with single detached houses where the owner owns the land and the entire building, why would I want someone telling me what color I can or can not paint my house? telling me my dish is 6" to high, or too large, or that I can only have one? You have to look at it on the flip side too, what service is the HOA providing me that I desperately need? I cant find one yet, and haven't heard anyone suggest one either. The "so people dont have their area look like the dump with non working cars and trash everywhere" comment is covered under pretty much all city bylaws, don't need a HOA for that. Here where I live I can only have one uninsured vehicle on the property and if the city deems my property unsightly with garbage then they can fine me. This is pretty standard.
Do single detached homes with HOA also pay a fee to the HOA?
UDL