It seems to me D downrezs everything. I have both Dish and Direct and there is no comparison between the two when it comes to HD. Dish wins handsdown. I only have Direct for the baseball programming and the few games I have watch on their BHD channel, especially the Yankee games looks pretty washed out compared to the games last year on Dish when they had baseball. I am hoping they get this fixed this year because I am wavering towards Direct, so I don't have two systems, but if their HD doesn't get better then I will have to think real hard about it. I know it isn't my plasma because I have seen both sats and there was no adjustment needed on the Dish reception. Just my two cents worth.