I did figure in the Tivo costs, but even at less than $9 per month each (though I think my 2nd will be less), I am still ahead given that my home phone is at around $50 per month for very basic service and the Internet access would be $40 per month. Dish would have a really hard time competing with that. I will miss the remote on the 522. I wasn't overawed during my brief time playing with my new Tivo. Though I did want to have it ready when I get Fios so I can just start with the CableCard.
Brad
Brad