I went with DirecTV. The new HR34 5 tuner dvr is awesome. I also got a second HDDVR for my sons room. I now never have to worry about not having enough tuners to record what I want at any given time; What what I record does not have any effect on what anyone else in the house watches. All my TVs are now in HD. I can watch any recording from either DVR in any location in the house. By taking advantage of all the new customer promos, refer a friend and every discount I could find. I will save right at $350 over the course of the next two years vs staying with dish and that is even after paying an upfront $198 equipment fee. I also think the HD picture quality is a little better. In a nut shell Better Equipment, Picture, and Price.