I'm sure that FOX faced backlash from the NFL and WWE. Don't forget that FOX paid over a billion for one wrestling show and has the pressure on the WWE to deliver ratings. I'm sure the WWE was sitting there, like the NFL, wanting access to as many homes as possible.
FOX can't complain about ratings to either company, when its having a proverbial peeing contest with the number 2 satellite television provider. Then to add the demand to blackout Thursday Night Football on NFL Network.
Essentially there are arguments that either side caved. The truth is we will never know. In my opinion, Dish said "take your HBO and Cinemax, and shove it." They told Univision to shove it. They went as far as to create their own competitor to The Weather Channel, be it for one day, but I'm sure it was a message well received that they weren't playing around. They kept FX, National Geographic, and so on off Dish for a month. Remember the AMC debacle? What I'm saying is that Dish has a history of not giving a damn if channels are pulled. So, to blindly say that FOX won and Dish caved (without any evidence) is just fan fiction at this point.
If I was betting on this, Dish made some concessions and FOX made some concessions. Dish is paying more, but FOX isn't getting nearly what they originally demanded. It's called negotiations.