Well I just spent the last couple of hours reading through this whole thread. Next, I'll have to download the file and actually read it.
I now have a bigger dilemna than I had a few days ago. I've been a D* customer for 6 years. I have 2 Directivo's with a combined capacity of 400 hours. They're connected to a channel plus modulator allowing me to access each of them on any of my 8 TV's (I used to have 7 Directivo's until I came up with this solution a couple of years ago).
I do not, however, have HDTV. I have the capability in my HT with my PJ and 126" screen, but I've been waiting until I upgraded my living room TV this summer. With all of the problems with D* lately (going away from tivo, HD lite, leasing, etc.), I've been researching FiOS for the last couple of weeks. It's available where I live and I already have their phone service and next week I'll be getting their internet.
Now, FiOS also has a few issues with thier DVR, but everything I've read lends me to believe that their fixes will be coming soon. Apparently, they'll also be coming out with a distribution system fairly soon. Combine that with the PQ reviews I've seen and the cost and I determined that FiOS was a no-brainer for me.
Now, after reading through this thread I'm not so sure. Maybe I should stick with D* for awhile longer and see how it shakes out. Decision, decisions.
D* has always treated me pretty well (but since my bill isn't over $100, I guess I'm only 3 hearts) and I have lifetime service on my DVR's so I guess I should give them the benefit of the doubt.
However, when I'm ready to upgrade to HD this summer, if FiOS has the kinks worked out of their HD-DVR, are close to having a distribution system (which is important with 8 TV's) and can increase the capacity of their DVR (we currently have about 80 SP's), it will be very hard to wait on D*.