I think I finally convinced the wife that this is what we should do to help cut back on expenses. Even with dropping FiOS TV/Internet and going with cable internet and even the monthly TiVo fee if we can't find a good deal on lifetime we would still be saving about $50 a month, and I could pipe in the locals to the other two TVs in the house which just have Rokus on them now.
If you cannot get a good deal on an used TiVo with lifetime, I would definitely buy the Romeo 4 Tuner. I have 2 of them. They also work with the TiVo minis to allow you to watch in other rooms.