The Masterpiece has considerably better gain numbers for UHF and VHF.I think I'd go with an 8 bay bow-tie type antenna with a good pre-amp.
I just installed 2 masterpiece antennas. I have the masterpiece 100 aimed toward Chicago and a masterpiece 45 aimed at South Bend. Alone they work great.
Alone I get 19 channels on the masterpiece 45 from South Bend and 32 channels on the masterpiece 100 from Chicago. When I use a 1ghz splitter to combine them I only pick up 23 channels on the scan with Chicago channels being pixelated. Any suggestions?
An A/B switch or a rotator may help.That's because each antenna is picking up a little of the signal from the opposite antenna, and the phase shift cancels (or messes up) the reception. The easiest solution, is either separate antenna coaxs into a coax switch (bad if you aren't around to manually switch back and forth), or TWO ATSC tuners/dvr's, each getting an input from an antenna.
Or, you can try rotating one or the other antenna's to a slightly different azimuth, that MAY lower the signal slightly, yet find that possible balance point that'll allow both of them to work acceptably. It's kind of voodoo, but it might be doable.
There's your sign.The are both in the attic about 50 foot apart