Correct - IF YOU want a free phone. NOT IF THEY CALL YOU and say - excuse me, but YOU HAVE TO upgrade your perfectly fine phone - AND sign a 18 month committment.
But you dont HAVE to upgrade, just if you WANT to keep Voom.
This is the same crap the Comcast subs are whining about while Comcast is switching analog channels to digital to make room. People want to sit in their little bubble while they are left behind by technology.
This is nothing new, mpeg4 did not happen yesterday.
Here's my selfish view(and its not selfish to me because Ive been looking ahead):
If you bought a tv(for primary use) in the last 2 years and it wasnt an digital tv, uh, not so smart(Ive bought 2).
If you got a box from E* in the last year and it wasnt mpeg4 capable, uh, not so smart.(Ive bought a HR20 and 622 in the last year)
If I was sitting there with a 921 or whatever the heck it is Id be saying:
"hmmmm, free 622 upgrade for 18 mo's commitment and Im getting more hd with Voom going mpeg4. Sign me up!"
No, we get the guys that say "I bought a 921 2 years ago and have no contract, now they want to go do something stupid like upgrade the hd programming and it means Ill have to sign up for 18 more mo's or loose the channels.BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"