This is law for you. Honestly, there were a number of ways they could go. Each having a proper "logic" in itself. I turned around my position on it from where SCOTUS ruled after a thorough thread at this forum.
This feels similar to IRS cases, where someone feels they found a perfect loophole. But in the end, the spirit of the law trumps the letter of the law.
This feels similar to IRS cases, where someone feels they found a perfect loophole. But in the end, the spirit of the law trumps the letter of the law.