How much baking soda to water ratio do you use? Do you basically make it a thick paste or is it still mostly powder but seems to have slight moisture? This one talks about the various cleaning methods for contacts but still no mention of carbonated soft drinks or baking soda. Vinegar (white or apple cider) followed by baking soda will probably work too. Seems like ammonia is probably what gets rid of the tarnishing.I use the baking soda to neutralize the acid that leaks out of most batteries when they fail. Then just make sure
the contact is clean and dry. Shiny is also nice to see if the connector isn't too corroded.
I have a lot of X10 stuff in my house and a lot of remotes for that system. Seems that the one battery end that gets corroded inside a remote is always the hardest one to get to.
Contact Cleaning: The Right Stuff
Here is a link to how to make contacts look new with vinegar and baking soda.
How to Perfectly Clean Wires in Minutes!!!