I am a current Dish customer and they did this box thing with an old receiver I had hanging around from my 921 purchase/install. I guess the 921 installer was a subscontractor, but he didn't know what was supposed to happen with my box, and I couldn't remember if I had owned it or not. The installer didn't know what to do with it, and I know that when I had D* removed I owned their basic boxes and had them in a cupboard forever too before I got rid of them.
So I had it in a cupboard forever, and suddenly out of the blue I started getting really ,really nasty voice messages from Dish saying I had something of theirs and I had to return it.
Eventually (a few weeks later) a box showed up, but I went out of town on a business trip for a few days. I was going to get the thing shipped back on Saturday when I had time, but suddenly on like Tuesday a UPS guy shows up saying he was there to pick up the box. Only by a fluke was someone home when he came to know why he had even come, but we sent him away saying it wasn't ready. He came back 2 more days (no one there).
That saturday, as I had planned, I took the big "you crook you stole Dish equipment box" to be shipped at a UPS store. That was a great 3 block walk for me. Granted, strangers don't give a damn what you are carrying but I felt very embarressed just the same since the box really makes you look like a criminal. Sent a really pissed email to Dish and never got a response. They treated me like a criminal for something that I think is entirely their fault - not having made arrangements for returning the box when they scheduled my install, even if it was just a matter of shipping the box then.
By the time this came up I didn't really know what the heck they were talking about. And I found it very embarressing to have the box left in a public area of my biulding too - it has lots of big, big type on it saying, basically "you have dish equipement and if you don't return it right away you are stealing it."
As a CURRENT Dish customer, I was flumoxed. I couldn't believe they would treat someone who pays them $100 a month without fail the way they did. I nearly canceled my service at that point. And I still frankly hate Dish. If it weren't for their channel line up, I would have left already.
Sorry, I don't think this is a "sometimes a company screws up" kind of issue. I think they have a deep and severe cultural problem about customer service. I know from my experience there was absolutely no reason for them to treat me as they did.
From my perspective, D* and E* are like, hmm, ISP's. I don't want to go to the trouble of changing my ISP all the time, but I am not subscribing to one or another because I love my ISP - I subscribe because I want to get to the internet. Here, I subscribe because I want channels. Unfortunatekly, UNLIKE an ISP, I can't get everything I want with all carriers, and right now Dish has an edge.
But as a company, I think they kind of suck.