Here is the thing. If the installation summary (first picture you posted) does not list 61.5 after running a check switch, you don't have reception of it, period. It doing that on the point dish screen means that it looked on the port it expects 61.5 to come from (port 3) and didn't find something, which makes it default to another LNB (in your case, 72.7). Once the receiver realizes that 72.7 is being received when 61.5 was asked for, that is when the receiver changes the bar to red to let you know something is wrong. This takes a few seconds.
You need to keep adjusting skew until running check switch lists all 3 sats on install summary, because until then what you get on point dish is inaccurate.
The manual for the 1000.4 says your skew should be 67, and dishpointer.com says 66. So i would adjust it up or down a degree until you see something. Another option is putting aluminum foil over the 77/72.7 LNBFs (the ones next to each other) so that the receiver does not confuse the signals, until you get a lock on 61.5