I'll say TiVo too. R-15 seems to have a lot of "bugs" in it along with a lot of other unwanted surprises. At least with TiVo you'll know what you're getting. In another post, I compared it with buying a new car the first model year, which is something I'd never do. Just read tonight that 15% of DirecTV's 15 million subscribers have TiVo. Thats 2,250,000. That many people can't be wrong.