I choose
5) No, I'm giving it a bit longer.
I went with E* after being gone for years. Was going to D*, but their up front costs were ridiculous. Looks like their HD DVR has dropped in price, which makes things a bit more attractive. My dad gave me a 722 (long story) that I own, I bet I could sell that to pay for the HR-21's I'd need.
(I still hate PAYING for leased hardware and taking a contract, but...)
The deciding factor will be when BSG airs. If I can't see it in HD, I'm switching. That's in March.
In the meantime, with the writers strike, there's so little on that I find myself just netflixing or reading.