PBS to DBS: Carry Our HDTV Signals!

Poke

Pub Member / Supporter
Original poster
Dec 3, 2003
13,886
238
OK
http://www.tvpredictions.com/pbs021207.htm

Public broadcasting officials want Congress to force satellite TV operators to offer high-def channels.

By Phillip Swann

Washington, D.C. (February 12, 2007) -- Public Broadcasting officials say satellite TV operators should be required to carry their High-Definition signals.

PBS executives from across the country are coming to Washington this week to urge Congress to change the Communications Act to include a must-carry provision.

"DIRECTV and EchoStar use scarce public airwaves to beam their signals to and from satellites," says John Lawson, president and CEO of the Association of Public Television Stations (APTS). "They use highly valuable international orbital slots for these satellites. It's outrageous that they won't carry the new digital channels from local public stations, but find a way to carry the big four commercial network stations."


DIRECTV and EchoStar have expanded their local HD service over the last year, but do not offer the PBS high-def signal in most cities.

APTS says the Communications Act should state that the satcasters must carry PBS' "entire multicast digital programming," which would include the high-def signal and other digital feeds.

Satellite TV services are required to carry the analog feed of the local PBS station under the Satellite Home Viewer Improvement Act.

APTS says DIRECTV is considering carriage of PBS digital feeds, but talks are at an early stage. EchoStar, the group says, is refusing to carry the PBS digital feeds.

In January 2005, the PBS group signed an agreement with the National Cable and Telecommunications Association for carriage of all PBS digital signals on large cable TV systems. APTS says it hopes to sign a similar agreement with smaller cable systems in the near future.
 
Talk about misuse of public airwaves, tell PBS stations to put their whole bandwidth into the HD channel, and stop diluting it with 4 or 5 SD subchannels.
 
I'll second that!

If they really were concerned about the public, they'd feed one national signal. They're just trying to support every little local station. Times change. PBS no longer offers unique material.
 
John Lawson said:
"DIRECTV and EchoStar use scarce public airwaves to beam their signals to and from satellites," says John Lawson, president and CEO of the Association of Public Television Stations (APTS). "They use highly valuable international orbital slots for these satellites. It's outrageous that they won't carry the new digital channels from local public stations, but find a way to carry the big four commercial network stations."
One thing has nothing to do with the other. Just because Satellites broadcast from FCC assigned slots, they must carry your stations? STFU! DBS carries plenty of FCC mandated PI channels. So STFU! If you want to be on dbs, then make a deal instead of running to congress every time you don't get your way.

Hell, dbs should run a "defund PBS" campaign just for equal time.
 
I wish they had the local HD version of our PBS channel though. It has some really great shows that aren't available elsewhere.
 
I wish they had the local HD version of our PBS channel though. It has some really great shows that aren't available elsewhere.

I agree. I wish they would sign up PBS HD on a national basis. No need to waste several hundred spotbeam channels when one National one will suffice.

Voyagerbob
 
I'll second that!

If they really were concerned about the public, they'd feed one national signal. They're just trying to support every little local station. Times change. PBS no longer offers unique material.

Even those constant beggings for pledges? I thought that was unique to each station. I dunno. I haven't tuned in for ages, although I do go to WNJN on election nights to get local info.....
 
grendyl-

Would that be in "HD" on subchannel -1, with SD on -2, -3, -4, ......?


Actually, one national feed in REAL HD would be nice. But their claim of "no commercials" is a farce. Their promos used to be less offensive than commercials- now they're just as bad.
 
Ours (WGVU-DT / WGVK-DT) has three, but runs only two at a time. SD on 35.2 & 35.3 until around 6 pm. HD begins at 6 pm until 6 am on 35.1 with 35.2 running as SD. 35.3 (Create!) is shut down while HD on 35.1 is running.

OTA HD picture quality is very good.
 
In OKC, PBS sends a fiber to Cox with a 24 hour HD feed, undiluted. See here. That's extending preferable treatment to a commercial provider, to the exclusion of competitors. OTA HD has to squeeze into the airwaves with the stupid subchannels.
 
The ATSC system was designed to allow one HD signal in the 6 MHz bandwidth. Sometimes stations try to sneak in an SD channel with it. At that point, on a larger TV such as my 61" - you see really bad pixellation in scenes such as a field of grass waving in the breeze. With 3 SD channels, I can't imagine watching. In fact, I don't, since WETA went to one HD channel simulcast with 3 SD. It's unwatchable if there is any movement.
 
What a waist my PBS is. I do not donate anymore.

My Nebraska PBS only has the HD PBS feed on from 7pm to 10pm. The rest of the day its that analog sub channel create and kids stuff.

Why dont they just have ONE national PBS feed on Direct and Dish avl for ALL.
Then they could do the sub channel junk all day long.
 
I am a very recent convert to PBS, primarily because of their nightly HD block. I was so hungry for anything HD, that i often stopped on PBS and ended up learning a boat load...I actually made sure i remembered to watch part two of the series "The Supreme Court" - whodathunkit? I now find myself watching PBS nearly every night, or at least checking to see what's on. UNFORTUNATELY now that Dish has killed the EPG subchannels, it is a PITA to know what's on PBS HD (in Austin, PBS HD is, i guess, considered a sub even though it is 18-1) I now find myself going to my local PBS website every day to find out what's on. I could live with a National PBS feed, though, especially if it was 24/7, and not just 8pm - 1am.
 
"...Why dont they just have ONE national PBS feed on Direct and Dish avl for ALL...."

Because they want their local stations to survive with local fund drives and locally sold commercials- err, not "commercials" - promos? :rolleyes:
 

D* may be better for sports BUT....

MPEG artifacts fixed with Mpeg 4

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

Who Read This Thread (Total Members: 1)

Latest posts