Directv by far has the biggest bang for the buck as far as a new customer is concerned, at least for 2 yrs. Depending on equipment & programming the 2 providers will be fairly close in price. Directv just had a price increase, so you will be good for another year in that regards. Dish hasn't had 1 in a while & expect a doozy of an increase next year this time. The history channel, ESPN, hallmark or whatever is the same stuff regardless of who you get it from. In my opinion a person is better off to get it from the cheapest source they can, if that means Dish for 2 years, Directv for 2 years, cable, fios, u verse or whoever. I fully 100% encourage churn to the cheapest provider. New customers get the best deals...............& it also encourages the very principles this country was founded on.
This is what I have written down as notes from my research. Please note my family currently has four old CRT TVs (we will get HDTVs later on when the old ones die/have problems).
--
Time Warner Cable (one bill and company):
$52.99 (regular Internet package)
$24.50 (local broadcast TV)
$19.99 (whole house HD (backward compatible with 4 CRT TVs) DVR rental
$43 ($10 + $33 ($11 extra for each additional) = 4 HD Box Receivers for 4 TVs
$49.99 for installation charge
Total = $140.48 ($87.49 per month for TV service)
Price Details:
http://www.timewarnerla.com/pricingguides/PDFs_2012/2008_PL-0112.pdf
--
Dish (cheapest TV service and already have a Dish and coax cables from previous house owners):
Welcome Pack (no HD channels like Family Pack) --
DISH - Entertainment - Packages - Welcome Pack
DISH Network for a $100 Amazon gift card (expires on 5/20/2012). 04AMZN for the code.
$14.99 (local broadcast channels + 40 extra; not shown when online ordering [have to ask for it and its difference would be credited with an active account])
$28 = Receiver ($14 (two TVs) + $14 (2 TVs due to $7 for each extra TV))
$6 = DVR Service
$6 for equipment protection plan
$10 for HD addon (for future HDTVs whenever that is)
Free installation.
Total = $54.99(no Chinese and HD)-$64.99(HD) per month
--
DirecTV (two years contract):
Entertainment Package (140+ channels) --
English Packages - DIRECTV :
$54.99 regular price per month after its promotion.
$29.99 per month promotion for a year with a 2 years contract.
$5.99 protection plan
Includes free 1 HD DVR + 3 HD receivers (advanced receiver service; $99 for another if needed), and 4,000+ VoD access.
Free installation.
International TV Channels | Watch International TV Shows Available on DIRECTV for international channels ($19.99 to $39.99)
Total = $60.98 per month after promotion.
--
I hope Dish one is correct and really the cheapest of all three. Please kindly let me know if I missed something and/or have something incorrect.
Also, there's no FIOS on this Verizon area.