I would think Rogers might have a case for City-Winnipeg to be added back. Back when they dropped Global Maritimes, CTV Edmonton, CBC Regina, CITY Winnipeg and Sun TV - The CTV station came back because of public pressure, CBC because of a CRTC ruling IIRC. Sun TV is sort of irrelevant now but I found it a little odd that Global-Montreal got added before the deleted Maritime station but Montreal is a larger market so that is the probable reason. Most of the dropped stations have been dealt with but we have one more Global Station than before they rationalized some of the duplicate stations. I would think they (Shaw) would make the effort for City-Winnipeg just to avoid the appearance of favouritism for standard broadcast stations.
For the specialties they could argue and maybe even show that the demand from the BDU's they supply with HD signals that HGTV was in demand.