I have a 10 ft mesh dish with a center lnb support that i can adjust in or out. I have geosat lnbf mounted, so when I got the dish i just mounted the lnbf on the existing mounting distance and had to move lnb in ( was about 3" sticking out from scalar ring). I thought since the lnb should stick out about 1/4" then I could move the support in and move the lnb back to get my 1/4" sticking out from scalar and I would get a much better signal. It didnt work so then I did my calculations and got a f/d of 48" but still not a good sig. Any suggestions on distance of scalar ring and why I got my better signals with the lnb sticking out 3 to 4 inches in front of the scalar? Also any suggestions on the best lnb without a servo?
I'm reading this thread a bit late, but just had to comment on a couple things. I assume it was just a typo, but the 48" is not the f/d, that's got to be the focal length, assuming that you've done the calculations right. That would calculate to an f/d of about 0.4. And that focal length is NOT where you position the scalar ring, that should be measured to about 1/4" inside the throat of the feedhorn. And although in many cases, it's easier to adjust the focal length by moving the throat of the feed inside the scalar ring, the correct procedure is to first set the position of the feed in the scalar, based upon the f/d, THEN, position the scalar so that the throat of the feed is at that 1/4" less than the focal length. This is not easy, since it usually means adjusting 4 feed support arms , 3 of which are often out of reach. What I have done (which I don't really recommend, but it's easy), is to loosen the bolts that connect the scalar to the support arms, then twist the whole scalar so that the support arms come in more tangentially than radially. This effectively reduces the focal length adjustment, and twisting the other direction so that the support arms come in radially toward the center makes the focal length adjustment longer. Again, I don't recommend this, but it's the only way I could find to do the adjustment without a major effort to get to the very top support arm connections to the dish, which on my spinclination IS dooable, but it's still a major project, and I'm lazy.
Anyway, I got the impression (maybe wrong) that you were leaving the position of the fixed at the focal length position, and moving the feed in and out for best signal. This isn't proper, and if done this way, I think you might be peaking on a side lobe instead of the main lobe. You might check to see if when on your south sat, you get two apparent peak positions when adjusting the elevation setting on your dish.