He's on the east coast...near NY/NJ area IIRC
Thank you Ice.... I attached a more "appropriate" EIRP map for this sat regarding the NY, NJ and upper east coast area. It is easy to see that there is quite a difference in the "estimated" signal power there vs where I am. I consider myself lucky to be located where I am in relation to the reception of this sat.
Manny, I would opt for a 1.2 M dish where you are located in order to obtain the best reception from this sat (in most weather conditions). You may already be able to pick up the SD channels from Hispasat with the dish you currently have, but this is simply a recommendation for best results from the "SatBeams" site.
I take the "recommendations" from any site with a vague sense of accuracy. They never seem to specify whether they mean that the dish size is recommended for the worse case scenario (bad weather) or if they mean the smallest recommended dish size during clear weather and best conditions overall.
Your initial question has a double edge sword in regards to the fact that you need a good reception strength to begin with. If you can get the Cubavision TP (11.884 V) with really good strength, then you should be able to pick up the 11.909 TP, too and utilize it
with the proper receiver. Then the other edge of the sword is obviously the receiver model and type.
My personal judgment is that if you can already receive the Cubavision TP with high or excellent strength and (more importantly) high quality, then you should be OK with a receiver that can handle the DVB-S2 signal from the 11.909 TP.
Currently, my Q level on 11.884 is 72% and the Q level on 11.909 is 58%, so there is a notable difference between these two TPs, at least from my reference location. I cannot say that my results will apply to your location in the same manner. I can only assume that your 11.909 TP will display weaker. Someone from the NE US needs to confirm their results and differences between the various TPs on this sat first. Being so far away from your location, and in a very different EIRP zone it is hard for me to say.
RADAR