I doubt that. Even DirecTV admitted that their great gains in net sub numbers were at the expense of "quality" customers that had been the tradition at DirecTV. Mike White said they would be TIGHTENING qualifications for new subs and upgrades and working harder to get more "quality" subscribers, like DirecTV used to do. Dish grew tremendously in the past, but that was because they had lower quality subs to get the numbers. Funny because DirecTV did a Dish, and now they are getting back to being DirecTV again.
As for Charles, he has taken his virtual NO growth for some time now as an opportunity to cull his low quality subscribers, as well, and focus on higher quality subs, and focus on getting upgrades in packages and upgrades in equipment for his current subs, and it seems to be working, overall. Both CEO's have said higher quality subs can weather down economies far better and less likely to cancel or even downgrade. They learned this from the recent economic downturn. So, Dish is now doing a DirecTV from the early days.