No, But then again, A DVR from DISH or DTV (DISH is better) can record shows that YOU tell it to. On Demand are shows the CATV Co downloads for you without your choice.
With a DISH DVR you can have the receiver tune to channels while you sleep or away at work and record them. You create your own On Demand programming.
Here is a review of the DISH 625 DVR
http://www.dbsinstall.com/Dish_Network/Receivers/Dish_Network_625_Receiver.asp
But at the store it is $300-$500 plus $10 month. With Satellite it is FREE and only $5/month.
Nope an HD DVR with DirecTV is more like 300 upfront plus 5 bucks a month lease fee. On Demand is great and I'll give you "one" reason why. Better yet I'll give "one" word why.
1. "Dexter".
Sometimes I hear about a great show like Dexter about five weeks after it started. In my case the first 10 shows of Dexter were out before I heard how great the show was. So with Showtime On Demand I spent one entire night watching all 10 shows back to back to catch up. My only problem was that I was so pissed off having to wait two more days for the 11th show to premier which I watched live as I couldn't wait lol.
Also with all the HD Movies On Demand from Encore and Starz for example its much better to watch them On demand instead of recording them on the HD DVR. Just remember with only about 15 hours of HD recording a two hour movie takes up way more room when I nearly fill it just with Fox and CBS on their own. Also TNT will start offering movies in HDTV via On Demand for free and the best part they won't be edited for content nor time and will have no ads. You can't record that on TNT HD that is for sure. I believe its best to enjoy both On Demand "and" an HD DVR because both combined can give an experience that can't be beat. Just don't underestimate what real benefits On Demand can provide that you cannot get via a DVR. The Dexter example is the perfect example of what On Demand can do that a DVR cannot do.
I understand the concept of On-Demand and I think its the best thing to ever happen to tv since HD. Imagine not waiting for a show to come on HBO or showtime just turn to the on-demand channel and BOOM instant entertainment.. With a DVR id have to wait for it to come on and be recorded... With on-demand iControl the TV..
PS: Cable offers DVR to, its not an exclusive feature to dish.. However it apears on-demand is. Yet antoher reason to choose cable over frypans...
It doesn't matter if you have to wait for the dvr to record the show. Reason being by the time you are ready to watch it the show has been downloaded. So in my oinion it's just as good as video on demand.
Ron
SatelliteCompanies will have on DEMAND soon.
Do a search for DishONLINE.
What I mean by wait is like on HBO.. Say a movie you wanted to see you notice it comes on 3 days from now at like 12AM midnight. so isntead of waiting till that time, goto the on-demand station and click bam watch it right then and their..
When it comes to network tv, say i wanna watch HOUSE (my fav show) then i have to record it on my dvr wait about 30min then i watch it so i can ffwd the commercials.. FOX doesnt have an on-demand and they would show house on the network first then put it on-demand.. On-demand is great for catching up o na new show you just got hooked on..
I think some of you must understand that this service was never intended as a DVR replacement ever. Its a specific service that is marketed towards a specific segment of customers. It just so happens that a very very high percentage of DVR customers are included within this segment. I see nothing wrong with a DVR customer enjoying the best of both worlds because the fact is that On Demand has quite a bit of content not even offered on any channel for recording. For example nearly all of the free movies On demand via Comcast aren't available on any of the normal channels. Also its not a big deal but Starz On Demand has what they call Early Premiers which are simply movies available about a month before they even air on the main Starz channel and many of them are in HDTV as well. Also some people can't seem to afford a DVR along with Starz for example so for them they might feel better off skipping the DVR and enjoying all the On Demand.
OK< but givent he choice i'd take the dvr any day of the week. The only thing that tempts me with On Deman and that is Howard TV.
ron