Fast forward to October 2015: Peyton Manning will put up 370 yards with 5 TD's in a blowout win over Jacksonville. For the next week the Jim Nantzs and Phil Simms of the world will fawn over Mr. October calling him the Greatest QB of all time. Seriously, I for one am sick and tired of this happening EVERY FRIGGIN' YEAR even though we know how this story ends in January. Peyton Manning is one of the five greatest QBs of all time, but when you have NINE one and dones and your record is 2-5 AT HOME following a first round bye, this precludes you from ever sniffing GOAT status!! Period and end of discussion!! Admittedly I'm biased towards Tom Brady, but if for whatever reason you don't like Brady, fine. I lean towards Joe Montana myself RIGHT NOW, but that could change in three weeks. But Peyton Manning? Sorry, the window has closed on him to be considered GOAT. However, he is IMO, the greatest REGULAR SEASON QB of all time