I have the Protection Plan (or whatever the official name of it is; they have changed the name of it too often), and I was NEVER charged any shipping fee when I returned 2 leased receivers that I no longer wanted on my account. At least I believe they didn't charge because of my enrollment in Protection Plan. I got FREE shipping it back to them. Yes, I too, have heard of Dish charging shipping to return leased receivers that you no longer want on your account. I'm sure from their view, YOU are the one costing THEM money if they were to take back the leased boxes. I still think it a bit PETTY for Dish to charge as people are STILL customers. It's not the as if Dish is letting the door hit you on the way out when you cancel service/account, which they do, in fact, do when one leaves, but I think even that is not a good way to end a business relationship.